Want healthy meals your kids will love?

Best Multivitamin for Kids: Researched Based Recommendations

25 Comments

If you are looking for a multivitamin for your kids, it can be overwhelming with the number of options out there. This is your complete guide to help you decide if your child needs a multivitamin, and which one is the best to give them.

Should I Give My Kids a Multivitamin?

A lot of parents wonder if they should be giving their kids a multivitamin. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics “healthy children receiving a normal, well-balanced diet do not need vitamin supplementation over and above the recommended dietary allowances.”

In general, the recommendation by medical professionals are that kids who eat a balanced diet that includes all food groups don’t usually need vitamin or mineral supplements. There are definitely exceptions and a multivitamin can help fill in the nutrition gaps for kids.

How Do I Know if My Child has a Nutrient Deficiency?

A nutrient deficiency in kids occurs when a child has an inadequate intake of the necessary amount of a specific nutrient or when their body doesn’t absorb a specific nutrient properly.

Kids and teens need the nutrients from a variety of foods to support their growth and development.  A nutrient-rich diet plays an important role in your child’s mental and physical development. They should be eating a variety of foods from these groups on a regular basis:

  • Fruits and Vegetables
  • Whole grains
  • Legumes
  • Nuts and Seeds
  • Lean proteins

What if your child isn’t getting the nutrients they need from food? It might be a good idea to supplement with a vitamin. A multivitamin is a good choice in some circumstances, but it depends on the nutrients your child needs. Keep reading to determine what and if you should look into a vitamin for your kids.

Symptoms of inadequate nutrient intake from food can look like:

  • being underweight, overweight or obese
  • constipation or changes in bowel habits
  • being pale or lethargic
  • tooth decay
  • poor physical growth

If a nutrient intake deficiencies isn’t reversed, it can lead to longer term health problems including stunted growth, digestive issues, skin problems, and poor bone development.

When Should I Give My Child a Multivitamin?

Of course it is ideal to get all your vitamins and minerals through food, but it is also a good idea to give your kids a multivitamin if there are nutrition gaps in your child’s diet. 

If your child falls into one of these categories, it may be a good idea to give them a multivitamin:

  • Follows a vegetarian or vegan diet
  • Has a medical condition that affects the absorption of or increases the need for nutrients, such as celiac disease, cancer, cystic fibrosis
  • Had surgery that impacts the intestines or stomach
  • Picky eater and struggles to eat a variety of foods

Some other reasons your child might not be getting enough nutrients from food:

  • Food Allergies – Children with food allergies may experience problems such as food aversion, food refusal, food neophobia, and anxiety about eating in general, which can lead to inadequate nutrient intake in addition to the nutrients missing from the foods they need to avoid.
  • Independent Food Choices and Restricted Diets – As kids get older and become more independent they may decide to follow particular diets or restrict certain food groups which can result in nutrient deficiencies in their diet.
  • Limited Access to Nutrient Rich Foods – Many kids just do not have access to enough of the food that gives them the nutrients they need on a daily basis.
  • Over Consumption of Processed Foods – If your child is eating a lot of high sugar, high sodium processed foods and beverages, they are likely not eating enough fruits, veggies, whole grains and protein leading to nutrition gaps.

Most Common Nutrient Deficiencies in Kids Ages 4-18

Based on the most recent NHANES (National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey) the current intake for the majority of kids in the United States show that from an early age, overall diet quality is poor.

This is based on average intake of the different food groups compared to recommended intakes as well as exceeding the recommended limits for added sugars, saturated fat and sodium. The Healthy Eating Index score declines throughout childhood and adolescence, with scores for adolescents approximately 10 points lower than those for young children.

The most common nutrient deficiencies in school age kids are: calcium, vitamin D, iron, and magnesium. These are reasons your child might be low in these nutrients and food sources of each.

Calcium

Your child might need more calcium if they:

  • have a lactose intolerance
  • have a milk allergy
  • eat a vegan diet
  • avoid dairy foods in general

Symptoms of Low Calcium:

  • muscle aches, cramps, spasms
  • pain in thighs and arms when walking or moving
  • numbness and tingling in hands, arms, feet and legs

Foods high in Calcium:

  • milk
  • yogurt
  • cheese
  • dark greens like broccoli, kale, chard
  • white beans red beans, chickpeas
  • calcium fortified cereal, bread and juice

Vitamin D

Recently, vitamin D deficiency has become very common because of the lack of sun exposure and there are not many natural foods that contain adequate amounts of vitamin D. Vitamin D is needed for healthy bones and to help your body use calcium. It has been studied heavily and has also been shown to help with the immune system, cardiovascular health. Reasons for low Vitamin D:

  • Inadequate sun exposure
  • Darker skin color
  • Low intake of Vitamin D rich foods

Symptoms of Low Vitamin D

  • Skeletal Diseases – rickets and osteomalacia
  • Increased respiratory infections
  • Food allergies
  • Asthma
  • Earlier start of menarche

Foods High in Vitamin D

  • Salmon
  • Tuna Fish
  • Fortified milk
  • Fortified orange juice
  • Fortified cereals

Iron

Iron is one of the most common nutrient deficiencies in kids. Reasons your child might have an iron deficiency:

  • Kids under 5 who drink more than 24 ounces of milk a day
  • Eat a vegetarian or vegan diet
  • Endurance athletes, especially those who menstruate

Symptoms of Iron Deficiency Anemia:

  • Feeling very tired and weak
  • Frequent headaches
  • Low energy
  • Pale skin
  • Shortness of breath

Foods High in Iron

  • Meat, fish, poultry
  • Lima beans, kidney beans, chickpeas
  • Fortified breakfast cereal and bread
  • Raw spinach and broccoli

Magnesium

Magnesium and calcium work together to make sure muscles function properly. Magnesium helps muscles relax and works to activate Vitamin D and Calcium to make strong bones. It also helps keep the heart beating regularly, supports your immune system especially when it is under stress and can improve sleep.

Your child might have low magnesium intake if they:

  • Have extreme dietary restrictions
  • Have a digestive disorder
  • Eat mostly processed foods

Symptoms of Magnesium Deficiency

  • Moodiness, irritability
  • Difficulty Concentrating
  • Insomnia
  • Loss of appetite
  • Nausea/Vomiting
  • Fatigue and weakness

Foods High in Magnesium

  • Dark leafy greens (spinach, kale)
  • Nuts and Seeds
  • Legumes
  • Fortified grains
  • Salmon, halibut
  • Bananas, Carrots and Apples

What Should I Look for in a Multivitamin?

If you are concerned that your child is deficient in a specific vitamin or mineral, a simple blood test at the doctor will be able to tell you. It you are considering supplementing, it is a good idea to get their levels tested. This is especially important with iron because there are potentially harmful effects of taking too much supplemental iron.

How to Choose a Vitamin for Your Child

  1. Determine which vitamins they might not be getting from their diet or that they are deficient in
  2. Make sure the nutrients included are close to 100% of the DV for all essential vitamins (unless you are looking to supplement a specific vitamin at a higher dose because of a deficiency)
  3. Look for a vitamin that that is specifically made for kids
  4. Should not include high fructose corn syrup or artificial sweeteners
  5. Third party testing to ensure the vitamin contains what it says it contains

Top Recommendations for Kids Multivitamins

I chose the following vitamins based on a few criteria:

  • Ingredients.  All the products I recommend are made with safe, high quality ingredients and contain no artificial flavors, food dyes, or high fructose corn syrup.
  • Age Appropriate. I only included products that are specifically formulated for kids.
  • Reputable brands. These vitamin products are from well-known brands that adhere to strict manufacturing standards.

Overall Best Multivitamin

Pros:

  • Consumer Labs tested and is the top rated vitamin for kids out of hundreds of brands
  • Includes iron and calcium (not found in gummy vitamins)
  • Ages 2-Teen
  • Reasonable Price

Cons:

  • Tablets might be hard to chew for toddlers
  • Not gluten free
  • Does not contain magnesium

Best Gummy Vitamin

Pros:

  • Contains Omega-3s EPA and DHA
  • Yummy tasting gummy
  • Gluten Free

Cons:

  • Have to take 4 gummies per day
  • Does not contain iron or calcium
  • Ages 4+

Best Multivitamin + Probiotics

Pros

  • Contains probiotics
  • Made with vegetarian pectin
  • Only need to take 1 per day

Cons

  • Does not contain iron or calcium
  • Expensive

Best Liquid Multivitamin

Pros

  • Easier for some kids to take
  • Adjustable dose for kids to start as young as 6 months
  • Contains calcium

Cons

  • Does not contain iron
  • Needs to be refrigerated

Consistency is Key with Vitamins

Just like getting the benefits of eating nutrient dense food, you only get the benefits of taking needed vitamins when you take them consistently. I have found this is the hardest part of taking vitamins – remembering to take them! Here are a few strategies I have found that work for us:

  • Take them the same time everyday. Choose whether you take them in the morning or evening and stick with that.
  • Take them when you are doing something you are already in the habit of. My kids take their vitamins in the evening right before they brush their teeth. When they get ready to brush their teeth, it trigures them to remember that they need to take their vitamin.
  • Keep a visual to help remind you. Because children’s vitamins can look and taste good, I wouldn’t recommend keeping them out in the open. But maybe its a picture, or empty bottle that helps you remember.

Safety of Multivitamins for Kids

If you follow the recommended directions and dosages on the bottle of the vitamin you choose, they should be safe for your child. There are some nutrients that can be toxic if ingested in too high amounts which is why you should always be the distributor of vitamins to your kids.

One nutrient that is of particular concern is iron. It is a needed nutrient, but can be toxic if too much is taken. If your child’s multivitamin contains iron, make sure you keep it in a place that kids can’t get too.

Resources

Multivitamin and Multimineral Supplements Review. Cooperman, Tod M.D., ConsumerLabs.com 12/20/2021

Vitamins and Minerals. NCCIH. 2/2018

Position of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics: Micronutrient Supplementation. Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. 11/2018

Micronutrient Requirements of Children Ages 4 to 13 Years. Drake, Victoria J. Ph.D., Updated 4/12/19

Dietary Guidelines for Americans 2020-2025.

Natalie Monson

I'm a registered dietitian, mom of 4, avid lover of food and strong promoter of healthy habits. Here you will find lots of delicious recipes full of fruits and veggies, tips for getting your kids to eat better and become intuitive eaters and lots of resources for feeding your family.

Learn More about Natalie

Leave a Comment:
Did you make this recipe? Leave a review!

Your email address will not be published.

25 Comments

What’s your take on the fiber gummy vitamins? Are the better or worse than the powder???

Natalie, I don’t think EITHER one is necessary. If anything Fiber is the one thing that really should be gotten in food.
Cathy, your book list looks a lot like mine.

I am also wondering what vitamin you recommend. For the past couple of years we’ve just used the chewable Flintstones to help us out. But my sister-in-law recently sponsored my almost 7 year old with her Juice-Plus order, so we get the Fruit “vitamin” and the Veggie “vitamin”. Any thoughts on those? We’ve been doing that for a few days now. He is taking one in the morning and the other at night…with lots of water.

I’m so sorry Melissa and Venessa. This is the second time I’ve been asked this question, and I keep putting off answering it, because I haven’t really formed an opinion yet. My kids take generic vitamins once in a while, which I’ve never really checked the label, but will start due to Dr. Fuhrman’s recommendations. A balanced diet is going to have all the nutrients our kids need, and shouldn’t need to be supplemented.
That said, I do like the Juice-plus type vitamins! (if they weren’t so expensive) These and other “whole food” vitamins I believe are better than synthetic ‘nutrient only’ supplements. We just found some much less expensive at Costco called Zoots. My kids do take these when I remember.

When I have some time to compare labels, I will update you!

Can you please suggest some that fit this criteria? Ideally not one that you have to give 4 gummies a day!

Hi Steph, thanks for reaching out. This is an older post that we haven’t visited in a while. We believe that whole foods are the best sources of vitamins and minerals for kids. I know that many parents like to have a multivitamin as a kind of “insurance policy” to fill in nutritional gaps, but our dietitians recommend focusing on food instead. (Even if you have picky eaters. It’s totally a work in progress for all of us!) I know I’m not exactly answering your question but I hope this perspective helps!

It can be tricky finding a children’s vitamin in a pill form- we haven’t tried any, but I would look for one that has natural ingredients and no added sugar. Good luck!

Wonderful information. The vitamins I give my kids are VitalVits by JoySpring. I’m suuuuper picky when it comes to vitamins and have been using VitalVits for a while now. They come in liquid form and aren’t terribly expensive. I chose these vitamins because the ingredient list is all plants.. extremely nutritious plants like nettle, alfalfa, parsley etc. They have a sweet flavor (no sugar in these vitamins). I usually squirt three dropper fulls in smoothies. So easy and nutritious!

We eat a mostly vegetarian diet and my son doesn’t love beans. He also needs to gain weight. His doctor recommends a multi with iron. Any recommendations for that? So far, we use Flintstone Complete Chewable, but I’m wondering if there is a better brand. None of the gummy vitamins contain iron. Thanks!

Zarbee’s Naturals makes a children’s gummy vitamin + iron. You can find it on Amazon! Best of luck!

My husband, son and I have been taking Juice Plus for several years. Based upon the scientific studies that have been conducted, we believe it is an EXCELLENT food supplement. I was curious if you are familiar with JP and if so, your thoughts about it?

What do you think of all the added sugar in some of these children’s vitamins? Some of them have five grams of sugar and in particular the sugary gummies cause cavities.

We recently listened to a health podcast where the hosts were raving about Hiya vitamins as the best children’s vitamin on the market so last month we officially switched and so far our kids LOVE their Hiya vitamins. Plus i love the clean ingredients.

And the bottle they send is so cute. 🙂

Thanks!

We do like to check the sugar content in our vitamins. Thanks for sharing your experience with Hiya vitamins. We’ll have to check them out!

I agree with the commenter Jessie. We recently switched to Hiya vitamins after hearing the Hiya founder on a podcast and was immediately sold because the message of no sugar and transparency with kids vitamins just makes sense. We ordered and love it.

Erin — I heard that podcast too! The Hiya founder was amazing and is why we switched from gummies to Hiya (plus it’s actually how I found this article haha!)

Hehe sounds like I’m not the only one here who likes Hiya! We recently bought Hiya too because of an article I read on another blog. It feels like a brand I’d buy for myself…more than a kid’s brand…and I guess that’s one reason I like it so much.

I really appreciate this post. I’ve been looking all over for this! Thank goodness I found it on this blog. You have made my day! I think this is an engaging and eye-opening material. Thank you so much for caring about your content and your readers.

We tried a few of these and eventually settled on Hiya (www.hiyahealth.com) based on advice from our functional medicine doctor. What sold me (apart from our doc’s advice) is it’s 100% dedicated to kids, so it’s not an adult label with a kid’s option slapped on, plus it’s eco-friendly and has great ingredients that we checked closely.

With respect, so much of this post is a bit dated — which is why I agree with the comments about Hiya being the best. Its so much better than the sugary gummies suggested here. Hiya forever.

We do our children a disservice when we pretend vitamins should be like candy. So while I respect your writing this, I just can’t get behind any of these companies. The gummy bears teach awful health habits for kids!

It’s why the only children’s vitamin I really trust is Hiya, which is what I give my two daughters. Our functional medicine doctor AND their dentist agrees with me that Hiya is far better than any of these options, considering the added sugar and gummy stuff that gets caught in teeth.

[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]